TLDR A regional performing arts organization implemented a Lean Culture framework to tackle rising production costs, declining audience engagement, and internal resistance to change. The initiative resulted in a 20% reduction in production costs and an 18% increase in ticket sales, highlighting the importance of effective Change Management and continuous improvement in achieving operational efficiency and employee engagement.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Background 2. Unveiling Operational Inefficiencies: The Starting Point 3. Crafting a Lean Culture Framework for Performing Arts 4. Engaging Stakeholders and Navigating Change 5. Executing Lean Culture: A Step-by-Step Implementation Journey 6. Lean Culture Best Practices 7. Transformative Consulting: The Path to Lean Culture 8. Tracking Success: Metrics and Monitoring in Lean Culture 9. Reaping the Rewards of Lean Culture Implementation 10. Additional Resources 11. Key Findings and Results
Consider this scenario: A regional performing arts organization implemented a strategic Lean Culture framework to address operational inefficiencies and improve overall performance.
The organization faced a 25% increase in production costs, declining audience engagement, and internal resistance to change, which impeded its agility and adaptability. Additionally, external factors such as fluctuating funding sources and competition from emerging entertainment platforms exacerbated these challenges. The primary objective was to embed Lean Culture principles to enhance operational efficiency, foster a culture of continuous improvement, and secure long-term sustainability.
In an era where operational efficiency can make or break an organization, a renowned performing arts entity embarked on a transformative journey. Faced with surging production costs, declining audience engagement, and internal resistance to change, the organization needed a robust strategy to turn the tide. This case study delves into the strategic decisions and methodologies employed to implement a Lean Culture framework, aiming to revitalize the organization's operations and financial health.
By integrating Lean principles with Strategic Planning and Performance Management, the organization sought to eliminate inefficiencies, foster a culture of continuous improvement, and enhance audience engagement. The insights and outcomes from this initiative provide valuable lessons for other performing arts organizations grappling with similar challenges. Read on to discover how a holistic approach to Lean Culture can drive substantial operational and financial gains.
The initial assessment uncovered a range of operational challenges. Production costs had surged by 25%, primarily due to inefficient processes and resource allocation. This increase strained financial resources, limiting the organization's ability to invest in new productions and talent. According to McKinsey, organizations that fail to optimize their operations can see costs rise by up to 30%, underscoring the importance of addressing these inefficiencies.
Audience engagement metrics painted a concerning picture. Attendance rates had declined steadily over the past 3 years, with a 15% drop in ticket sales year-over-year. This decline was attributed to a lack of compelling programming and ineffective marketing strategies. The organization struggled to compete with digital entertainment platforms, which offered more convenience and variety. A report from Deloitte highlighted that performing arts organizations need to innovate their engagement strategies to attract modern audiences.
Internal resistance to change emerged as a significant barrier. Employees were hesitant to adopt new methodologies, fearing job displacement and increased workloads. This resistance hindered the organization's ability to implement Lean Culture principles effectively. Change Management is critical in such scenarios, as noted by Bain & Company, which found that 62% of change initiatives fail due to employee resistance.
The assessment also revealed fragmented communication channels. Departments operated in silos, leading to misaligned objectives and duplicated efforts. This lack of cohesion contributed to operational inefficiencies and stifled innovation. A study by PwC indicated that organizations with strong internal communication are 50% more likely to report lower turnover rates and higher employee satisfaction.
The external environment added another layer of complexity. Fluctuating funding sources created financial instability, making it difficult to plan long-term projects. Additionally, emerging entertainment platforms posed a competitive threat, drawing audiences away from traditional performing arts. According to Gartner, organizations that fail to adapt to changing market dynamics often struggle to maintain relevance.
Best practices and industry benchmarks were considered during the assessment. The organization needed to adopt a holistic approach, integrating Lean Culture principles with Strategic Planning and Performance Management. This would ensure alignment of goals across all levels of the organization. Consulting firms like BCG emphasize the importance of such integrated approaches for achieving sustainable improvements.
In summary, the initial assessment provided a comprehensive understanding of the organization's operational challenges. Addressing these issues required a multifaceted strategy, incorporating Lean Culture principles, robust Change Management, and innovative audience engagement tactics. This foundational understanding set the stage for the subsequent development and implementation of the Lean Culture framework.
For effective implementation, take a look at these Lean Culture best practices:
Developing the Lean Culture framework began with a deep dive into the organization's unique operational landscape. The consulting team conducted extensive workshops and interviews with key stakeholders to identify pain points and opportunities for improvement. According to a Bain & Company study, involving employees in the early stages of Lean initiatives increases buy-in and reduces resistance by 40%. These insights were crucial for tailoring the Lean principles to the specific needs of the performing arts context.
The framework's foundation was built on the core Lean principles of eliminating waste, optimizing processes, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement. The team utilized Value Stream Mapping to visualize and analyze the flow of materials and information. This method helped identify non-value-added activities that accounted for nearly 20% of production time. Lean tools such as 5S and Kaizen were introduced to streamline operations and promote a clean, organized work environment.
Incorporating industry best practices, the framework emphasized the importance of cross-functional teams. Breaking down departmental silos was essential to ensure cohesive communication and alignment of objectives. A McKinsey report indicates that organizations with effective cross-functional collaboration are 30% more likely to innovate successfully. Regular inter-departmental meetings and collaborative problem-solving sessions were instituted to facilitate this integration.
Employee empowerment was another critical element. Lean Culture thrives on the active participation and initiative of all employees. Training programs were developed to equip staff with Lean tools and methodologies. According to Deloitte, organizations that invest in employee training see a 24% increase in productivity. Furthermore, suggestion systems were implemented, encouraging employees to contribute ideas for continuous improvement.
Performance metrics were established to track progress and ensure accountability. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) such as cycle time, defect rates, and employee engagement levels were monitored regularly. The use of dashboards and visual management tools provided real-time data, enabling quick decision-making and adjustments. Gartner's research shows that organizations leveraging real-time data analytics can improve operational efficiency by up to 25%.
The framework also integrated robust Change Management practices. Addressing internal resistance required a structured approach to change. Communication plans were developed to keep all stakeholders informed and engaged throughout the process. Bain & Company highlights that transparent communication can reduce resistance to change by 20%. Leadership played a pivotal role in modeling Lean behaviors and reinforcing the cultural shift.
Finally, the framework was designed to be adaptable and scalable. Regular review and refinement cycles were incorporated to ensure the Lean Culture evolved with the organization's needs. This adaptability was crucial for maintaining momentum and achieving long-term sustainability. According to BCG, organizations that continuously refine their Lean practices are 50% more likely to sustain improvements over time.
Engaging stakeholders was paramount to the success of the Lean Culture initiative. The organization implemented a comprehensive communication plan to ensure transparency and build trust among employees. Regular town hall meetings, newsletters, and intranet updates were utilized to keep everyone informed about the ongoing changes. According to a study by McKinsey, organizations with effective communication strategies are 3.5 times more likely to outperform their peers. This approach helped mitigate fears and fostered a sense of inclusion and ownership.
Training programs were a cornerstone of the Change Management strategy. Customized training sessions were developed to equip employees with the necessary Lean tools and methodologies. These sessions included hands-on workshops and e-learning modules, catering to different learning preferences. Deloitte's research indicates that companies investing in comprehensive training programs experience a 37% increase in employee engagement. Empowering employees with knowledge and skills was critical for fostering a culture of continuous improvement.
Overcoming resistance required targeted interventions. The organization identified key influencers within each department who could champion the Lean Culture initiative. These influencers were provided with additional training and resources to lead by example and support their peers. According to Bain & Company, leveraging internal influencers can reduce resistance to change by up to 30%. This peer-led approach helped in diffusing resistance and accelerating the adoption of new practices.
Feedback mechanisms were established to ensure continuous improvement and address concerns promptly. Regular surveys, suggestion boxes, and feedback sessions were conducted to gather input from employees. This feedback loop allowed the organization to make necessary adjustments and demonstrate responsiveness to employee needs. PwC's study shows that organizations with robust feedback mechanisms are 50% more likely to achieve successful change outcomes. This iterative process was crucial for maintaining momentum and engagement.
Leadership played a crucial role in modeling the desired behaviors and reinforcing the cultural shift. Senior leaders actively participated in Lean training sessions and were visible in their support for the initiative. They communicated the vision and benefits of Lean Culture through various channels, emphasizing the long-term value for both the organization and its employees. According to a report by BCG, visible and committed leadership is a key factor in the success of Change Management initiatives.
Cross-functional collaboration was encouraged to break down silos and promote a unified approach to problem-solving. The organization established cross-departmental teams to work on Lean projects, ensuring diverse perspectives and expertise were leveraged. A McKinsey report highlights that cross-functional teams are 35% more likely to deliver successful outcomes. This collaborative approach fostered a sense of shared responsibility and enhanced the overall effectiveness of the Lean Culture initiative.
Celebrating small wins and recognizing employee contributions were essential for sustaining motivation. The organization implemented a recognition program to highlight individual and team achievements in Lean projects. These celebrations were communicated through internal newsletters and social media, creating a positive reinforcement loop. According to Gartner, organizations that recognize employee contributions see a 14% increase in performance. This recognition helped in building momentum and reinforcing the desired cultural shift.
The implementation process commenced with a comprehensive diagnostic phase. The consulting team conducted thorough workshops and interviews to gather insights from all levels of the organization. This phase was crucial for understanding the unique challenges and opportunities within the performing arts context. According to a Bain & Company study, organizations that involve employees early in Lean initiatives see a 40% reduction in resistance. These insights informed the customization of Lean principles to fit the organization's needs.
Following the diagnostic phase, the team developed a detailed implementation roadmap. This roadmap outlined specific actions, timelines, and responsibilities. Key milestones included the initial rollout of Lean training programs, the establishment of cross-functional teams, and the introduction of Lean tools such as Value Stream Mapping and 5S. A McKinsey report indicates that clear, actionable plans are critical for successful Lean implementations, reducing ambiguity and aligning efforts across the organization.
Lean training programs were rolled out to equip employees with the necessary skills and knowledge. These programs included hands-on workshops, e-learning modules, and on-the-job training sessions. Deloitte's research shows that companies investing in comprehensive training see a 24% increase in productivity. Training was tailored to different roles within the organization, ensuring relevance and practical application. This approach empowered employees to contribute actively to the Lean transformation.
Cross-functional teams were established to drive the Lean initiatives. These teams were tasked with identifying inefficiencies, proposing solutions, and implementing changes. Breaking down departmental silos was essential for fostering collaboration and ensuring cohesive communication. A report from BCG highlights that organizations with effective cross-functional collaboration are 30% more likely to innovate successfully. Regular inter-departmental meetings facilitated this integration and alignment of objectives.
Performance metrics were established to track progress and ensure accountability. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) such as cycle time, defect rates, and employee engagement levels were monitored regularly. Dashboards and visual management tools provided real-time data, enabling quick decision-making. Gartner's research indicates that organizations leveraging real-time data analytics can improve operational efficiency by up to 25%. These metrics ensured transparency and facilitated continuous improvement.
Change Management was a critical component of the implementation process. Structured communication plans were developed to keep all stakeholders informed and engaged. Leadership played a pivotal role in modeling Lean behaviors and reinforcing the cultural shift. According to Bain & Company, transparent communication can reduce resistance to change by 20%. Regular updates and town hall meetings helped maintain momentum and address any concerns promptly.
Feedback mechanisms were established to ensure continuous improvement. Regular surveys, suggestion boxes, and feedback sessions were conducted to gather input from employees. This feedback loop allowed the organization to make necessary adjustments and demonstrate responsiveness. PwC's study shows that organizations with robust feedback mechanisms are 50% more likely to achieve successful change outcomes. This iterative process was crucial for maintaining engagement and refining the Lean Culture framework.
Celebrating small wins and recognizing employee contributions were essential for sustaining motivation. The organization implemented a recognition program to highlight individual and team achievements in Lean projects. According to Gartner, organizations that recognize employee contributions see a 14% increase in performance. These celebrations created a positive reinforcement loop, helping build momentum and reinforcing the desired cultural shift.
To improve the effectiveness of implementation, we can leverage best practice documents in Lean Culture. These resources below were developed by management consulting firms and Lean Culture subject matter experts.
The consulting process began with a comprehensive diagnostic phase. The team conducted in-depth workshops and interviews with employees at all levels. This phase was crucial for identifying the root causes of inefficiencies and resistance. According to McKinsey, organizations that involve employees in the early stages of Lean initiatives experience a 40% increase in buy-in. These insights formed the foundation for a tailored Lean Culture framework.
Workshops played a pivotal role in the consulting methodology. These sessions were designed to educate employees on Lean principles and gather their input on existing challenges. Interactive activities, such as Value Stream Mapping and root cause analysis, were employed to engage participants. Bain & Company notes that hands-on workshops can reduce resistance to change by 30%. This collaborative approach ensured that the framework was both practical and well-received.
Collaborative sessions with key stakeholders were integral to the process. These sessions facilitated open communication and alignment of objectives across departments. Cross-functional teams were established to drive Lean initiatives, breaking down silos and fostering collaboration. According to a report by BCG, organizations with effective cross-functional teams are 35% more likely to achieve successful outcomes. This integration was essential for cohesive implementation.
The consulting team utilized proven Lean tools and methodologies. Techniques such as 5S, Kaizen, and PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) were introduced to streamline processes and promote continuous improvement. A study by Deloitte highlights that companies implementing Lean tools see a 24% increase in productivity. These tools were customized to fit the unique needs of the performing arts organization, ensuring relevance and effectiveness.
Performance metrics were established to monitor progress and ensure accountability. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) such as cycle time, defect rates, and employee engagement levels were tracked regularly. Real-time dashboards provided visibility into performance, enabling quick decision-making. Gartner's research shows that organizations leveraging real-time data analytics can improve operational efficiency by up to 25%. These metrics facilitated data-driven improvements.
Change Management was a critical component of the consulting process. Structured communication plans were developed to keep stakeholders informed and engaged. Leadership played a pivotal role in modeling Lean behaviors and reinforcing the cultural shift. According to Bain & Company, transparent communication can reduce resistance to change by 20%. Regular updates and town hall meetings helped maintain momentum and address concerns promptly.
Feedback mechanisms were established to ensure continuous improvement. Regular surveys, suggestion boxes, and feedback sessions were conducted to gather input from employees. This feedback loop allowed the organization to make necessary adjustments and demonstrate responsiveness. PwC's study shows that organizations with robust feedback mechanisms are 50% more likely to achieve successful change outcomes. This iterative process was crucial for maintaining engagement and refining the Lean Culture framework.
Celebrating small wins and recognizing employee contributions were essential for sustaining motivation. The organization implemented a recognition program to highlight individual and team achievements in Lean projects. According to Gartner, organizations that recognize employee contributions see a 14% increase in performance. These celebrations created a positive reinforcement loop, helping build momentum and reinforcing the desired cultural shift.
Establishing robust performance metrics was essential for monitoring the progress of the Lean Culture initiative. The organization identified Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) that aligned with its strategic goals. These included metrics such as cycle time, defect rates, and audience engagement levels. According to Gartner, organizations that track KPIs effectively can improve their operational efficiency by up to 20%. Real-time dashboards were implemented to provide visibility into these metrics, enabling quick and informed decision-making.
Cost reduction was a primary focus area. The organization aimed to reduce production costs by streamlining processes and eliminating waste. Lean tools such as Value Stream Mapping and 5S were employed to identify and remove non-value-added activities. According to a Deloitte study, organizations that implement Lean methodologies can achieve cost reductions of up to 30%. Regular audits and reviews ensured that these cost-saving measures were sustained over time.
Audience engagement was another critical metric. The organization tracked ticket sales, attendance rates, and customer satisfaction scores. Innovative marketing strategies and compelling programming were introduced to attract and retain audiences. A report from McKinsey highlights that organizations with strong audience engagement strategies see a 15% increase in revenue. By continuously monitoring these metrics, the organization was able to adapt its strategies to meet evolving audience preferences.
Internal process efficiencies were closely monitored. The organization established KPIs to track cycle times, defect rates, and employee productivity. Lean tools such as Kaizen and PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) were utilized to drive continuous improvement. According to Bain & Company, companies that adopt continuous improvement practices can increase productivity by up to 25%. Regular feedback loops and performance reviews ensured that these improvements were sustained.
Employee engagement and satisfaction were also key metrics. The organization conducted regular surveys and feedback sessions to gauge employee morale and involvement in Lean initiatives. According to PwC, organizations with high employee engagement see a 21% increase in profitability. Training programs and recognition systems were implemented to foster a culture of continuous improvement and ensure that employees felt valued and empowered.
The use of real-time data analytics was instrumental in tracking these performance metrics. Dashboards and visual management tools provided real-time insights into operational performance. According to a report by BCG, organizations that leverage real-time data can improve decision-making and operational efficiency by up to 25%. This data-driven approach enabled the organization to make timely adjustments and maintain momentum in its Lean Culture journey.
Regular review and refinement cycles were incorporated to ensure the Lean Culture framework remained relevant and effective. The organization conducted quarterly reviews to assess progress against established KPIs and identify areas for improvement. According to McKinsey, organizations that regularly review and refine their Lean practices are 50% more likely to sustain long-term improvements. This iterative process was crucial for maintaining alignment with strategic goals and adapting to changing market dynamics.
In summary, the establishment of robust performance metrics and monitoring systems was critical for the success of the Lean Culture initiative. These metrics provided visibility into operational performance, enabling the organization to make data-driven decisions and sustain continuous improvement. By tracking cost reductions, audience engagement, internal process efficiencies, and employee satisfaction, the organization was able to achieve its strategic objectives and secure long-term sustainability.
The Lean Culture initiative yielded significant improvements in operational efficiency and cost savings. The organization saw a 20% reduction in production costs within the first year, primarily due to the elimination of non-value-added activities and optimized resource allocation. According to Deloitte, companies implementing Lean methodologies typically achieve cost reductions of up to 30%, aligning with the results observed. This financial relief allowed the organization to reinvest in new productions and talent, fueling further growth.
Audience engagement metrics showed marked improvement. Ticket sales increased by 18%, reversing the previous trend of declining attendance. Innovative programming and targeted marketing strategies played a crucial role in this turnaround. A McKinsey report highlights that organizations with strong audience engagement strategies can see revenue increases of up to 15%. The organization leveraged these insights to tailor its offerings, meeting the evolving preferences of its audience.
Internal process efficiencies also saw substantial gains. Cycle times for production processes decreased by 25%, while defect rates dropped by 15%. The use of Lean tools such as Kaizen and PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) facilitated these improvements. Bain & Company notes that companies adopting continuous improvement practices can boost productivity by up to 25%. These efficiencies not only improved operational performance but also enhanced the overall quality of productions.
Employee engagement and satisfaction levels rose significantly. Regular surveys indicated a 22% increase in employee morale and a 19% rise in participation in Lean initiatives. Training programs and recognition systems were pivotal in this transformation. According to PwC, organizations with high employee engagement experience a 21% increase in profitability. The organization’s investment in its workforce fostered a culture of continuous improvement and innovation.
The integration of real-time data analytics proved invaluable. Dashboards and visual management tools provided actionable insights into operational performance, enabling swift decision-making. Gartner's research shows that organizations leveraging real-time data can improve operational efficiency by up to 25%. This data-driven approach allowed the organization to maintain momentum and adapt strategies as needed, ensuring sustained improvements.
Best practices and lessons learned were documented to refine the Lean Culture framework continuously. Quarterly reviews were conducted to assess progress against KPIs and identify areas for enhancement. According to McKinsey, organizations that regularly review and refine their Lean practices are 50% more likely to sustain long-term improvements. This iterative process ensured the framework remained aligned with strategic goals and responsive to market dynamics.
The success of the Lean Culture initiative underscores the importance of a holistic approach. By integrating Lean principles with Strategic Planning and Performance Management, the organization achieved substantial operational and financial gains. Consulting firms like BCG emphasize that such integrated approaches are crucial for sustained success. The organization's journey serves as a compelling case study for other performing arts entities aiming to enhance efficiency and secure long-term sustainability.
This case study exemplifies the transformative power of Lean Culture when integrated with Strategic Planning and Performance Management. The organization's journey from operational inefficiencies to significant cost savings and enhanced audience engagement serves as a compelling example for others in the performing arts sector. The initiative's success underscores the importance of a holistic approach, involving all stakeholders and leveraging robust Change Management practices.
Moreover, the role of real-time data analytics in driving operational efficiency cannot be overstated. By providing actionable insights and enabling swift decision-making, data analytics proved to be a critical component of the Lean Culture framework. Organizations aiming to replicate this success should consider investing in advanced analytics tools to gain a competitive edge.
Ultimately, the lessons learned from this case study highlight the value of continuous improvement and adaptability. Regular reviews and refinements of the Lean Culture framework ensure that the organization remains aligned with its strategic goals and responsive to market dynamics. This iterative process is crucial for sustaining long-term improvements and achieving lasting success.
Here are additional best practices relevant to Lean Culture from the Flevy Marketplace.
Here is a summary of the key results of this case study:
The overall results of the Lean Culture initiative were highly successful, demonstrating significant improvements in operational efficiency, cost savings, and employee engagement. For instance, the 20% reduction in production costs and the 18% increase in ticket sales highlight the financial and operational benefits achieved. However, the initial resistance to change posed challenges, requiring targeted interventions and robust Change Management practices. While the results were impressive, further refinement of communication strategies and continuous training could have accelerated the adoption of Lean principles even more.
Recommended next steps include conducting regular reviews to refine the Lean Culture framework, enhancing communication strategies to further reduce resistance, and investing in advanced analytics for deeper insights into operational performance. Additionally, expanding the recognition program can sustain employee motivation and engagement, ensuring the long-term success of the initiative.
Source: Transforming a Regional Performing Arts Organization through Lean Culture Strategy , Flevy Management Insights, 2024
Leverage the Experience of Experts.
Find documents of the same caliber as those used by top-tier consulting firms, like McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Deloitte, Accenture.
Download Immediately and Use.
Our PowerPoint presentations, Excel workbooks, and Word documents are completely customizable, including rebrandable.
Save Time, Effort, and Money.
Save yourself and your employees countless hours. Use that time to work on more value-added and fulfilling activities.
Operational Resilience Initiative for Mid-Size Truck Transportation Firm
Scenario: A mid-size truck transportation firm is struggling to embed a lean culture within its operations, facing both internal inefficiencies and external market pressures.
Lean Manufacturing Transformation for Electrical Equipment Manufacturer
Scenario: An established medium-sized electrical equipment manufacturer in the Midwest is struggling with a lean culture implementation amidst increased competition and rising material costs.
Transforming a Mid-Size Printing Company with a Lean Culture Strategy Framework
Scenario: A mid-size printing and related support activities company implemented a Lean Culture strategy framework to address declining productivity and rising operational costs.
Porter's 5 Forces Analysis for Education Technology Firm
Scenario: The organization is a provider of education technology solutions in North America, facing increased competition and market pressure.
Direct-to-Consumer Growth Strategy for Boutique Coffee Brand
Scenario: A boutique coffee brand specializing in direct-to-consumer (D2C) sales faces significant organizational change as it seeks to scale operations nationally.
Organizational Alignment Improvement for a Global Tech Firm
Scenario: A multinational technology firm with a recently expanded workforce from key acquisitions is struggling to maintain its operational efficiency.
Operational Efficiency Enhancement in Aerospace
Scenario: The organization is a mid-sized aerospace components supplier grappling with escalating production costs amidst a competitive market.
Sustainable Fishing Strategy for Aquaculture Enterprises in Asia-Pacific
Scenario: A leading aquaculture enterprise in the Asia-Pacific region is at a crucial juncture, needing to navigate through a comprehensive change management process.
Balanced Scorecard Implementation for Professional Services Firm
Scenario: A professional services firm specializing in financial advisory has noted misalignment between its strategic objectives and performance management systems.
Organizational Change Initiative in Luxury Retail
Scenario: A luxury retail firm is grappling with the challenges of digital transformation and the evolving demands of a global customer base.
PESTEL Transformation in Power & Utilities Sector
Scenario: The organization is a regional power and utilities provider facing regulatory pressures, technological disruption, and evolving consumer expectations.
Cloud-Based Analytics Strategy for Data Processing Firms in Healthcare
Scenario: A leading firm in the data processing industry focusing on healthcare analytics is facing significant challenges due to rapid technological changes and evolving market needs, necessitating a comprehensive change management strategy.
Receive our FREE Primer on Lean Management
This 32-page presentation from Operational Excellence Consulting explains the Lean Management philosophy, based on the Toyota Production System (TPS). Learn to eliminate waste. |