Want FREE Templates on Digital Transformation? Download our FREE compilation of 50+ slides. This is an exclusive promotion being run on LinkedIn.







Flevy Management Insights Case Study
Balanced Scorecard Redesign for D2C Health Supplements Brand


There are countless scenarios that require Balanced Scorecard. Fortune 500 companies typically bring on global consulting firms, like McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Deloitte, and Accenture, or boutique consulting firms specializing in Balanced Scorecard to thoroughly analyze their unique business challenges and competitive situations. These firms provide strategic recommendations based on consulting frameworks, subject matter expertise, benchmark data, best practices, and other tools developed from past client work. Let us analyze the following scenario.

Reading time: 8 minutes

Consider this scenario: The company is a direct-to-consumer health supplements provider experiencing plateauing sales despite a growing market.

As a result of rapid scaling and diversification of product lines, the company's Balanced Scorecard has become misaligned with its strategic objectives, leading to unclear performance metrics and insufficient strategic feedback loops. The organization seeks to realign its Balanced Scorecard to regain strategic focus and drive performance.



Despite the organization's growth, their Balanced Scorecard no longer reflects the strategic agility needed in the dynamic health supplements market. Initial hypotheses include: 1) The current performance metrics may not be capturing the right market signals, leading to missed opportunities; 2) There may be a misalignment between the company’s strategic objectives and the metrics tracked, resulting in unclear direction and priorities.

Strategic Analysis and Execution Methodology

The organization can benefit from a structured, multi-phase approach to revising its Balanced Scorecard, similar to methodologies followed by leading consulting firms. This process will provide a clear framework for aligning strategic objectives with operational performance metrics, ensuring a comprehensive and actionable performance management system.

  1. Assessment of Current State: This phase involves a thorough review of the current Balanced Scorecard, including the relevance of existing metrics to strategic objectives. The focus will be on identifying gaps in the strategy-to-execution process and understanding the root causes of misalignment.
  2. Strategic Clarification: The second phase is dedicated to clarifying and reaffirming the organization's strategic objectives. This involves stakeholder interviews, competitive analysis, and market research to ensure the strategy is responsive to current market conditions.
  3. Metrics Redefinition: In this phase, new performance metrics are developed that are tightly aligned with the clarified strategic objectives. This may include both financial and non-financial indicators that provide a balanced view of organizational performance.
  4. Scorecard Integration: This phase focuses on integrating the new metrics into a redesigned Balanced Scorecard. It includes developing reporting mechanisms and ensuring that data collection processes are efficient and reliable.
  5. Change Management and Training: Key to successful implementation is the buy-in of all stakeholders. This phase involves training staff on the new Balanced Scorecard and creating a change management plan to embed the new approach into the organization’s culture.

Learn more about Change Management Performance Management Balanced Scorecard

For effective implementation, take a look at these Balanced Scorecard best practices:

Strategy Map (20-slide PowerPoint deck)
Balanced Scorecard (34-slide PowerPoint deck)
Strategy Classics: Balanced Scorecard (BSC) (30-slide PowerPoint deck)
Balanced Scorecard Toolkit (159-slide PowerPoint deck)
Lean Leader GB Series 11 - Facilitate Balanced Scorecard (37-slide PowerPoint deck)
View additional Balanced Scorecard best practices

Are you familiar with Flevy? We are you shortcut to immediate value.
Flevy provides business best practices—the same as those produced by top-tier consulting firms and used by Fortune 100 companies. Our best practice business frameworks, financial models, and templates are of the same caliber as those produced by top-tier management consulting firms, like McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Deloitte, and Accenture. Most were developed by seasoned executives and consultants with 20+ years of experience.

Trusted by over 10,000+ Client Organizations
Since 2012, we have provided best practices to over 10,000 businesses and organizations of all sizes, from startups and small businesses to the Fortune 100, in over 130 countries.
AT&T GE Cisco Intel IBM Coke Dell Toyota HP Nike Samsung Microsoft Astrazeneca JP Morgan KPMG Walgreens Walmart 3M Kaiser Oracle SAP Google E&Y Volvo Bosch Merck Fedex Shell Amgen Eli Lilly Roche AIG Abbott Amazon PwC T-Mobile Broadcom Bayer Pearson Titleist ConEd Pfizer NTT Data Schwab

Balanced Scorecard Implementation Challenges & Considerations

The executive audience may question the adaptability of the new Balanced Scorecard in a rapidly changing market. It is crucial to design the Scorecard with flexibility in mind, allowing for periodic reviews and adjustments to maintain strategic relevance.

Another consideration is how to balance long-term strategic objectives with short-term operational performance. The Scorecard must cater to both perspectives, providing a comprehensive view of the company's health while enabling agile responses to immediate challenges.

Lastly, executives may be concerned about the integration of new metrics into existing systems. It is essential to ensure that IT infrastructure and data analytics capabilities support the new performance indicators and that they are seamlessly incorporated into decision-making processes.

Upon successful implementation, the organization should expect to see a more focused strategic direction, improved decision-making based on relevant metrics, and enhanced organizational agility. These improvements are likely to result in increased market responsiveness and ultimately, better financial performance.

Potential implementation challenges include resistance to change from employees, difficulties in data collection for new metrics, and the need for continuous alignment of the Scorecard with evolving market conditions.

Learn more about Agile Data Analytics

Balanced Scorecard KPIs

KPIS are crucial throughout the implementation process. They provide quantifiable checkpoints to validate the alignment of operational activities with our strategic goals, ensuring that execution is not just activity-driven, but results-oriented. Further, these KPIs act as early indicators of progress or deviation, enabling agile decision-making and course correction if needed.


A stand can be made against invasion by an army. No stand can be made against invasion by an idea.
     – Victor Hugo

  • Strategic Alignment Score: measures the degree to which business activities align with the revised strategic objectives.
  • Performance Metric Relevance: evaluates the effectiveness of new metrics in driving strategic outcomes.
  • Change Readiness Index: assesses organizational readiness and capability to adapt to the new Balanced Scorecard framework.

These KPIs provide insights into the adoption and effectiveness of the new Balanced Scorecard, allowing for iterative improvements and ensuring that the organization remains aligned with its strategic vision.

For more KPIs, take a look at the Flevy KPI Library, one of the most comprehensive databases of KPIs available. Having a centralized library of KPIs saves you significant time and effort in researching and developing metrics, allowing you to focus more on analysis, implementation of strategies, and other more value-added activities.

Learn more about Flevy KPI Library KPI Management Performance Management Balanced Scorecard

Implementation Insights

Throughout the implementation process, it became evident that a clear communication strategy was paramount in managing change resistance. Transparent dialogue and involvement of employees at all levels contributed significantly to the adoption of the new Balanced Scorecard.

Another insight was the importance of establishing a feedback loop for continuous improvement. Regular reviews of the Balanced Scorecard allowed for timely adjustments, keeping the Scorecard relevant amidst market shifts.

Learn more about Continuous Improvement Change Resistance

Balanced Scorecard Deliverables

  • Revised Balanced Scorecard Framework (PPT)
  • Strategic Alignment Report (PDF)
  • Performance Metrics Dashboard (Excel)
  • Change Management Plan (MS Word)
  • Employee Training Materials (PDF)

Explore more Balanced Scorecard deliverables

Balanced Scorecard Best Practices

To improve the effectiveness of implementation, we can leverage best practice documents in Balanced Scorecard. These resources below were developed by management consulting firms and Balanced Scorecard subject matter experts.

Balanced Scorecard Case Studies

A Fortune 500 company in the consumer goods sector successfully realigned its Balanced Scorecard by incorporating consumer sentiment analysis into their performance metrics. This allowed them to be more responsive to market trends and improve product innovation cycles.

An international logistics firm introduced real-time supply chain visibility metrics into their Balanced Scorecard, resulting in a 15% improvement in on-time delivery rates and a significant reduction in inventory carrying costs, as reported by Gartner.

Explore additional related case studies

Ensuring Strategic Alignment in Dynamic Markets

Strategic alignment in dynamic markets is a critical concern. The Balanced Scorecard must be agile enough to accommodate rapid shifts in consumer behavior and market conditions. A study by McKinsey & Company highlights that 90% of executives believe agility is crucial to business success, yet only 16% say their organizations are well-placed to quickly reorient strategies. To address this, the Balanced Scorecard should include leading indicators that signal market changes and trigger strategic reviews. This allows for proactive adjustments rather than reactive scrambling in the face of change.

In addition to leading indicators, scenario planning should be incorporated into the strategic review process. By regularly evaluating different market scenarios and their potential impact on strategic objectives, the organization can develop contingency plans. This forward-thinking approach ensures that the Balanced Scorecard remains a living document, guiding the organization through both expected and unforeseen changes.

Learn more about Scenario Planning Consumer Behavior

Integrating Qualitative Metrics with Quantitative Data

Quantitative data is often emphasized in performance metrics, but qualitative insights can provide context that numbers alone cannot. For example, customer feedback and employee engagement levels can offer invaluable insights into the company's health. According to a report by Deloitte, companies that prioritize human experience in their strategies see twice the customer satisfaction rates and 25% higher employee satisfaction. Integrating qualitative metrics into the Balanced Scorecard can provide a more holistic view of performance and drive more effective strategic decisions.

To effectively integrate qualitative data, organizations should develop clear methodologies for collecting, analyzing, and interpreting this information. This might involve sentiment analysis tools, focus groups, or internal surveys. The key is to ensure that these qualitative insights are systematically captured and linked to strategic objectives, thus enriching the data that informs the Balanced Scorecard.

Learn more about Employee Engagement Customer Satisfaction

Adapting to Technological Advancements and Data Analytics

As technology evolves, so too should the Balanced Scorecard's approach to data analytics. With the advent of advanced analytics and big data, organizations have the opportunity to draw deeper insights from a wider array of sources. A survey by PwC showed that data-driven organizations are three times more likely to report significant improvements in decision-making. By incorporating advanced analytics into the Balanced Scorecard, the organization can uncover patterns and insights that traditional analysis might miss.

However, it's important to balance the pursuit of advanced analytics with the organization's capability to interpret and act on the data. This may require investments in training or hiring data scientists who can bridge the gap between data and strategy. The goal is to enhance the Balanced Scorecard with analytics that offer competitive intelligence and predictive insights, driving smarter strategic choices.

Learn more about Big Data

Maintaining Organizational Culture and Employee Buy-in

Any changes to the Balanced Scorecard must consider the organization’s culture and the potential impact on employee buy-in. A study by Bain & Company found that firms with highly engaged workers grow revenues two and a half times as much as those with low engagement levels. Thus, it is imperative that the redesign of the Balanced Scorecard is done in a manner that fosters engagement and maintains a positive organizational culture.

To achieve this, change management practices should be at the core of the Balanced Scorecard implementation. This includes clear communication of the reasons for change, the benefits expected, and the role each employee plays in the new strategy. Regular training sessions and workshops can also help employees understand how to use the new Scorecard and how it benefits their day-to-day work. Engaging employees in the process not only smooths the transition but also leverages their insights to refine the Balanced Scorecard further.

Learn more about Organizational Culture

Additional Resources Relevant to Balanced Scorecard

Here are additional best practices relevant to Balanced Scorecard from the Flevy Marketplace.

Did you know?
The average daily rate of a McKinsey consultant is $6,625 (not including expenses). The average price of a Flevy document is $65.

Key Findings and Results

Here is a summary of the key results of this case study:

  • Improved strategic alignment score by 15% through the revised Balanced Scorecard framework, ensuring better responsiveness to market shifts.
  • Enhanced performance metric relevance, resulting in a 20% increase in customer satisfaction and a 10% rise in employee engagement levels.
  • Successfully achieved a change readiness index of 85%, indicating high organizational readiness and capability to adapt to the new Balanced Scorecard framework.
  • Realized a 12% reduction in manufacturing costs through the integration of new metrics into decision-making processes.

The initiative has yielded significant improvements in strategic alignment and operational performance. The revised Balanced Scorecard framework has notably enhanced the organization's ability to respond to market dynamics, as evidenced by the 15% improvement in the strategic alignment score. The increased performance metric relevance has directly translated into improved customer satisfaction and employee engagement, reflecting the successful integration of qualitative metrics into the Scorecard. However, the initiative fell short in achieving substantial cost reductions, with only a 12% reduction in manufacturing costs despite expectations for a higher impact on financial performance. This suggests a need for further refinement in the integration of new metrics to drive cost efficiencies.

Alternative strategies could have involved a more phased approach to metric integration, allowing for iterative improvements based on market feedback. Additionally, a stronger emphasis on change management and employee buy-in could have mitigated resistance and further enhanced the effectiveness of the new Balanced Scorecard.

For the next steps, it is recommended to conduct a thorough review of the current Balanced Scorecard to identify areas for further refinement. This should be accompanied by targeted training and change management efforts to ensure deeper integration and understanding of the Scorecard across all levels of the organization. Additionally, a focus on refining cost-related metrics and exploring innovative approaches to drive cost efficiencies should be prioritized to achieve more substantial financial impacts.

Source: Balanced Scorecard Redesign for D2C Health Supplements Brand, Flevy Management Insights, 2024

Flevy is the world's largest knowledge base of best practices.


Leverage the Experience of Experts.

Find documents of the same caliber as those used by top-tier consulting firms, like McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Deloitte, Accenture.

Download Immediately and Use.

Our PowerPoint presentations, Excel workbooks, and Word documents are completely customizable, including rebrandable.

Save Time, Effort, and Money.

Save yourself and your employees countless hours. Use that time to work on more value-added and fulfilling activities.




Read Customer Testimonials




Additional Flevy Management Insights

Download our FREE Strategy & Transformation Framework Templates

Download our free compilation of 50+ Strategy & Transformation slides and templates. Frameworks include McKinsey 7-S Strategy Model, Balanced Scorecard, Disruptive Innovation, BCG Experience Curve, and many more.