Editor's Note: Take a look at our featured best practice, A Comprehensive Guide to Change Management (586-slide PowerPoint presentation). This "new and improved" A Comprehensive Guide to Change Management,, which replaces my previous "best seller" of the same name, contains everything (well nearly everything) you would ever want to know about Change Management. This slide-deck now contains over 580 slides [read more]
Change: Measuring Outcomes
Also, if you are interested in becoming an expert on Change Management, take a look at Flevy's Change Management Frameworks offering here. This is a curated collection of best practice frameworks based on the thought leadership of leading consulting firms, academics, and recognized subject matter experts. By learning and applying these concepts, you can you stay ahead of the curve. Full details here.
* * * *
My article called 70% of Change Management Initiatives Fail–REALLY? has now hit over 5950 views along with 66 Likes and 21 Comments on LinkedIn.
In the main, this failure rate stems from none other than McKinsey and Company who since 2006 have surveyed some 6,800 “CEO’s and senior executives” who had experienced a significant performance transformation in the last 5 years.
Many have used this headline in a plethora of blogs, articles, and adverts, which have been used as a way for individuals and companies to generate business/sell their wares, be it consultancy services, seminars, workshops, etc.
In the article, I talk about how we measure success/failure in the context of change initiatives e.g.:
- The traditional way … measure success/failure against your original Business Plan in which there should be clear and detailed Business Benefits.
- Other ways…
- Measuring the relative contribution that change management provides to a project’s overall ROI, conducting an in-depth retrospective analysis of similar cases with like objectives to identify common investment criteria and parameters, measuring organizational readiness or agility for change.
- On time, on budget, all technical objectives met, all business objectives met, all human objectives met.
This has been the subject of many a previous debate here on LinkedIn, but, more importantly, I believe this should be an area of great interest to us “change practitioners,” because, in the face of the “70%” headline, we need to show how we add value and demonstrate we are actually good at what we do.
Interestingly, I recently found a blog from Prosci called Measurement to Determine the Return on Change Management, which kind of aligns to what I want to do. In it, their Chief Development Officer Tim Creasey and Master Instructor Scott Rossis discuss Prosci’s “Change Scorecard:”
So, what is it I want to do?
I want to see if there is enough interest in developing/participating in a survey to try and understand how “outcomes” (I call them that rather than focus on “success” or “failure”) are measured in the context of change initiatives.
Definition of an outcome:
- Merriam Webster: something that happens as a result of an activity or process.
- The Free Dictionary: something that follows from an action, dispute, situation, result, consequence.
- Business Dictionary: determination and evaluation of the results of an activity, plan, process, or program and their comparison with the intended or projected results. THIS ONE DOES IT FOR ME!
- Oxford Dictionaries: the way a thing turns out; a consequence.
The “doodle graphic” I have used at the top of this article is my initial attempt at some of the areas/questions that I think could be used as the basis of the survey, e.g.:
The left-hand side (1) being measurement related activity
- Project Plan.
- Measures Used.
- Implementation Outcomes.
The right-hand side (2) being supporting activity:
- Team Structure.
- Governance Structure.
- Type of Project.
Undoubtedly, there will be many others that I haven’t thought of.
The IBM Making Change Work Study actually do something similar every 3-years with input from some 1,500, what they call, “real life practitioners” such as:
- Subject Matter Expert/Reviewer.
- Project Team Member.
- Change Manager.
- Project Manager.
- Initiator/Project Sponsor.
But, hey!, I am no McKinsey or IBM or Prosci and I would never ever deign to try and compete with those venerable institutions. I am a mere mortal that thinks a survey of this kind developed by practitioners with input from practitioners would be kind of cool to do. And, I do like to do something that is maybe just a little bit different!
So, what exactly is it I am after?
In the first instance, I would like some “virtual” volunteers to help me to determine the focus of the survey and its structure & content… between 5 and 10 should do it (I already have two). I did something like this a couple of years ago with another survey and it worked well; e.g., we exchanged information and ideas via e-mail and Skype and eventually reached a consensus on the final survey. There are some caveats to this:
- The survey should be at a relatively simple level and not be overcomplicated.
- Volunteers should come from the “change practitioner” community and be actively involved in delivering change on a day-to-day basis.
- Anyone who volunteers should also take part in the survey.
My initial thoughts regarding the survey are:
- How do we select survey participants e.g.:
- There will already be those that respond to this article so “a bird in the hand is better than two in the bush” but potentially that will not attract enough people to make the survey sample representative? So do we …
- Put out a generic “do you want to participate” request in LinkedIn “change” related Groups? And/or …
- Message LinkedIn 1st “change” connections asking them if they would like to participate?
- How do we select on what basis we conduct the survey e.g.:
- Do we ask participants to select a specific Programme/Project?
- Do we ask people to suggest a number of Programmes/Projects in which they have been involved without letting us know the outcomes and then select one, some or all of them?
- How do we survey?
- Survey Monkey (I only have a basic account which limits me to 10 questions)?
- Word?
- Excel?
- Other?
- Length of survey e.g.:
- Should it be ongoing?
- Should there be a “please input before” date?
No doubt there will be many other considerations, but we can deal with these when the time is right.
I am not sure whether I am “biting off more than I can chew” but hey you never know until you try.
To volunteer, either contact me via LinkedIn (if you are a 1st connection), register your interest by leaving an appropriate comment or directly email to ron.leeman@thehighwayofchange.com and I will follow-up with you.
So over to you… either volunteer or make suggestions/comment, even if it is only to call me plain crazy for attempting such an undertaking!
Want to Achieve Excellence in Change Management?
Gain the knowledge and develop the expertise to become an expert in Change Management. Our frameworks are based on the thought leadership of leading consulting firms, academics, and recognized subject matter experts. Click here for full details.
"The only constant in life is change." – Heraclitus
Such is true for life, as it is for business. The entire ecosystem our organization operates in—our customers, competitors, suppliers, partners, the company itself, etc.—is constantly changing and evolving. Change can be driven by emerging technology, regulation, leadership change, crisis, changing consumer behavior, new business entrants, M&A activity, organizational restructuring, and so forth.
Thus, the understanding of, dealing with, and mastery of the Change Management process is one of the most critical capabilities for our organization to develop. Excellence in Change Management should be viewed as a source of Competitive Advantage.
Learn about our Change Management Best Practice Frameworks here.
Readers of This Article Are Interested in These Resources
|
73-slide PowerPoint presentation
|
|
19-slide PowerPoint presentation
| |||
About Ron Leeman
Ron Leeman has been involved in “change and process” work for more years than he cares to remember. He has worked extensively across the UK, Europe, and globally--and has an enviable track-record of delivering organisational change and process initiatives across a wide cross section of industry sectors. In 2012, Ron was bestowed with a “Change Leader of Tomorrow” award by the World HRD Congress “in recognition of my remarkable progress in initiating changes enough for others in the same industry to follow my example”. Ron is firm believer in knowledge transfer and now wants to share his vast knowledge with those who are considering getting into or at various stages of “change” and/or “process” work or those working on specific Projects wanting to gain practical insights into “how to” type situations. You can connect with Ron Leeman on LinkedIn here, where you can view his 85+ Recommendations and in excess of 800 Endorsements from clients and co-workers alike to give you an indication of the quality of service that he has provided and can offer. Ron is also a document author on Flevy. Browse his frameworks on Change Management, Process Analysis, and Program Management here: http://flevy.com/seller/highwayofchange.Top 10 Recommended Documents on Change Management
» View more resources Change Management here.
» View the Top 100 Best Practices on Flevy.