flevyblog
The Flevy Blog covers Business Strategies, Business Theories, & Business Stories.




The Fatal Flaw in Studying “Best Practices”

By Don Peppers | February 22, 2016

Editor's Note: Take a look at our featured best practice, Digital Transformation Strategy (145-slide PowerPoint presentation). Digital Transformation is being embraced by organizations across most industries, as the role of technology shifts from being a business enabler to a business driver. This has only been accelerated by the COVID-19 global pandemic. Thus, to remain competitive and outcompete in today's fast paced, [read more]

Also, if you are interested in becoming an expert on Customer-Centric Design (CCD), take a look at Flevy's Customer-Centric Design (CCD) Frameworks offering here. This is a curated collection of best practice frameworks based on the thought leadership of leading consulting firms, academics, and recognized subject matter experts. By learning and applying these concepts, you can you stay ahead of the curve. Full details here.

* * * *

6675297699_8bd0018d78_oNo matter what your business issue is, you can always find some “best practices” to analyze, by examining the companies or organizations that have had the most success in dealing with that issue. And many of us think that if we want to have more success ourselves, then all we really need to do is pattern our own policies and practices after those companies that have already had success.

If you want your company to do a better job when it comes to online marketing, then survey the most successful online marketers and note the strategies and tactics they have in common. If you want it to be financially successful over a long period of time, then look for companies that have in fact accomplished this feat, and identify the strategies they followed or the traits they possess.

In business, identifying best practices is a straightforward strategy for improvement. Hundreds, if not thousands, of business books, management tracts, and business journal articles are constructed around the idea that by carefully looking at those companies that have been highly successful in any given industry or task, other businesses can copy their strategies and practices in order to be successful too.

But while studying best practices sounds imminently logical, there’s a fatal flaw in this kind of analysis, because it’s actually based on a logical fallacy. You cannot predict how effective any business practice will be in the future by examining its past successes, unless you also look at its past failures.

Imagine, just for argument’s sake, that you are trying to devise a strategy for getting more “heads” on your coin tosses. If you carefully analyze a thousand coin tosses by different people who did get heads on their tosses, you will discover that about 90% of them were flipped with the right hand, rather than the left, which makes right-handed coin tossing a best practice.

Think that sounds ridiculous? Well let’s say you were to read in some business guru’s best-selling book that those companies that have achieved the most exceptional growth in innovative fields tended to be those that were willing to face up to disruptive forces and “bet the company” on new and equally disruptive plans or strategies. The book then catalogs five or ten of these success stories, outlining each of their cases in more detail and drawing comparisons, point by point, which gives us – voila! – a set of best practices.

It might sound logical at first, but what if you could find ten other companies that had adopted the same bet-the-company strategy and ended up going out of business, or being bought by their competitors? This would mean that the strategy isn’t actually a best practice at all. It’s simply a gamble not much different from a coin toss.

Rather than identifying firms that have been successful in the past and studying their practices, the right way to learn anything useful is to start with a hypothesis about some business practice that you think tends to make a firm successful, and then find a large sample of companies that have adopted this practice in the past, in order to see what proportion of them were, in fact, successful.

Of course, no books are written about failures, so failures are not as easy to identify. Few people are willing to talk at any length to a researcher, reporter or business writer about why they failed, or what it was like, and most business gurus don’t seem very interested in documenting the universe of failures, near failures, and successes just to be more “scientific” with their advice.

But that’s exactly my point. In most cases, the study of “best practices” isn’t scientific at all.

35-slide PowerPoint presentation
Digital Transformation touches practically every function in the entire organization. This thus requires an unprecedented amount of coordination among people, process, and technologies throughout the organization, leading to a difficult Transformation program. The Six Building Blocks of [read more]

Want to Achieve Excellence in Customer-Centric Design (CCD)?

Gain the knowledge and develop the expertise to become an expert in Customer-Centric Design (CCD). Our frameworks are based on the thought leadership of leading consulting firms, academics, and recognized subject matter experts. Click here for full details.

In the modern Digital Age, advances in technology and communication, combined with the explosive growth in data information, have given rise to a more empowered global customer. Recent economic and political events highlight the need for organizations to understand how consumers view the world and the most important attributes for their purchasing decisions.

Thus, increasingly more organizations are seeking to invest and focus on Customer-centric Design. A clear understanding of customer needs and behaviors across the organization will help drive profitable growth strategies and provide the confidence to invest in opportunities at a time when staying within budget can be extremely difficult.

Learn about our Customer-Centric Design (CCD) Best Practice Frameworks here.

Readers of This Article Are Interested in These Resources

56-slide PowerPoint presentation
Customer Experience is fast becoming the key business battleground in many markets. In order to be successful it is critical that all business create a Customer Experience Strategy, an all encompassing view of how they will deliver superb experiences to their customers. Having such a strategy [read more]

225-slide PowerPoint presentation
[NOTE: Our Design Thinking presentation has been trusted by an array of prestigious organizations, including industry leaders such as Apple, MIT, NASA, Ford, Boeing, Fujitsu, Syngenta, Palo Alto Networks, and Mercer, to name just a few.] Design Thinking is a process for creative problem solving. [read more]

143-slide PowerPoint presentation
Customer Journey Mapping is the process of creating a graphical representation of the steps and stages a customer goes through to experience a product, service, an online experience, or any combination. It may focus on a particular part of the process or the end-to-end experience. The journey [read more]

30-slide PowerPoint presentation
Delivering great customer experiences is one of the true differentiators of many of the great organisations of our time. However, delivering these great experiences doesnt happen overnight. Organisations need to become mature at all aspects of creating, delivering and improving customer [read more]