The newly mandated IIA Global Internal Audit Standards (GIAS 2024) place unprecedented emphasis on report quality, root-cause depth, commercial quantification, and formal Quality Assurance and Improvement Program (QAIP) governance.
The Internal Audit Report Evaluation Matrix (GIAS 2024) is a deterministic 6-sheet Excel tool that evaluates draft audit reports against 42 scored criteria. It replaces subjective editorial opinions with mathematical assurance gates, ensuring that only reports meeting rigorous executive and board standards reach the Audit Committee.
Core Architectural Features:
• Finding-by-Finding Scoring: Independently scores up to 20 findings across the 5 mandatory elements: Condition, Criteria, Root Cause, Commercial Consequence (EBITDA/Cash impact), and Management Action Plan feasibility.
• Engagement Close Mechanics: Assesses report turnaround velocity, audit workpaper cross-indexing, and executive management response quality.
• Automated Issuance Gate Rules:
• ACCEPT (85% or higher with zero critical gaps): Approved for distribution to the Audit Committee.
• REVISE (70% to 84%): Returned to the engagement lead for mandatory restructuring.
• WITHHOLD (Below 70% or unquantified critical risk): Distribution halted to protect the function's credibility.
Deliverables:
• Internal_Audit_Report_Evaluation_Matrix_GIAS_2024.xlsx: 6-sheet unlocked master workbook.
• Full operating methodology and scoring criteria guide.
• Complete commercial advisory and department distribution license.
100% Macro-Free | Fully Unlocked | Built for Chief Audit Executives and Quality Assessors.
Author Credentials and Institutional Standing:
Author & Architect: Majid Mumtaz (CIA, ACA, FCCA, GRCP, GRCA, COSO ERM Certified)
Practice: Director of Internal Audit & Risk Advisory / Audit Committee Secretary, Veritux Consulting Network
Executive Profile: Former Director of Internal Audit & GRC at Kitopi; Group Director of Internal Audit & Risk at Al-Faisaliah Group; Internal Audit Lead at McDonald's Saudi Arabia; Big 4 Alumnus (KPMG, EY).
Thought Leadership: Author of The Audit Signal (LinkedIn newsletter) and practitioner tools at .
Core Philosophy: Replacing retrospective 20-invoice sample compliance testing with automated 100% continuous controls monitoring (CCM) and operational telemetry directly connected to Board-level EBITDA protection.
Got a question about the product? Email us at support@flevy.com or ask the author directly by using the "Ask the Author a Question" form. If you cannot view the preview above this document description, go here to view the large preview instead.
Source: Best Practices in Audit Management, Compliance Excel: Internal Audit Report Evaluation Matrix GIAS 2024 Excel (XLSX) Spreadsheet, Majid Mumtaz